The Judiciary Under Siege: The Role of Civil Society in Insulating and Advancing Judicial Independence Público
Dvalishvili, Katerina (2017)
Published
Abstract
This thesis examines why in certain cases, judicial attacks on courts lead to an increase in levels of judicial independence. In the study of judicial politics, scholars have widely written about the importance of judicial independence in establishing and maintaining the rule of law. Despite the importance of an independent judiciary, judges often face a variety of politically motivated attacks that seek to limit their independence. While these attacks often decrease the level of independence, in certain cases, the level of judicial independence increases following the attack. I hypothesize that in cases of massive attacks, a robust civil society can mobilize to insulate the judiciary. The empirical findings from this study indicate that massive attacks very rarely take place in countries with robust civil societies. The rare instances in which massive attacks have occurred have all been in the context of major political crises. The key implication from these findings is that a robust civil society prevents attacks from occurring.
Table of Contents
I. Introduction .....................................................................................................................................1
II. Theory ...............................................................................................................................................2
Overview of the Role of Judiciary in Protecting "Rule of Law".........................................2
Importance of Judicial Independence to Rule of Law.........................................................4
Challenges in Defining the Term.........................................................................................5
Defining an
"Attack"...........................................................................................................8
Modes of
Attack......................................................................................................9
Variations in De Facto Judicial Independence...................................................................10
Preserving Judicial Independence: The Role of Civil
Society...........................................12
The Case of
Pakistan.............................................................................................17
Figure 1: LJI in Pakistan Over
time.................................................................21
III.
Hypothesis.......................................................................................................................................21
IV. Data &
Methodology..................................................................................................21
Independent Variable:
Attacks...........................................................................................22
Independent Variable: Civil
Society..................................................................................24
Figure 2: Histogram of Civil Society Index
..........................................27
Dependent Variable: Judicial Independence......................................................................27
Figure 3: Histogram of Latent Judicial Independence ..........................................................28
Control Variables and Fixed
Effects..................................................................................29
Empirical
Model................................................................................................................29
Ordinary Least Squares Regression......................................................................29
Instrumental Variables and Two Stage Least Squares
Estimation.......................30
Figure 4: Model with Instrumental
Variable...................................................31
V.
Results.............................................................................................................................................32
OLS
Results.......................................................................................................................32
Table 1: OLS Regression of
LJI...........................................................................33
Table 2: OLS Regression of LJI with Two-Year Time Lag.................................34
Table 3: OLS Regression of LJI with One-Year Time Lag..................................35
Table 4: OLS Regression of LJI with Five-Year Time Lag.................................36
Table 5: Countries with Massive Attacks and Robust Civil
Society....................37
IV and 2SLS
Results..........................................................................................................38
Exceptions to the
Study.....................................................................................................39
Argentina 1955 and
1958......................................................................................39
Argentina 1990.....................................................................................................40
Figure 5: LJI in Argentina Over Time.............................................................42
Ecuador 2004........................................................................................................43
Figure 6: LJI in Ecuador Over Time................................................................45
Ukraine 2014.........................................................................................................46
Figure 7: High Court Independence in Ukraine Over Time............................49
Fiji 1987 and 2000................................................................................................49
Figure 8: LJI in Fiji Over
Time........................................................................51
VI. Conclusion and
Implications..............................................................................................51
Linkages with Public
Support............................................................................................52
VII. References
...............................................................................................................................56
About this Honors Thesis
School | |
---|---|
Department | |
Degree | |
Submission | |
Language |
|
Research Field | |
Palavra-chave | |
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor | |
Committee Members |
Primary PDF
Thumbnail | Title | Date Uploaded | Actions |
---|---|---|---|
|
The Judiciary Under Siege: The Role of Civil Society in Insulating and Advancing Judicial Independence () | 2018-08-28 15:55:22 -0400 |
|
Supplemental Files
Thumbnail | Title | Date Uploaded | Actions |
---|---|---|---|
![]() |
attack_final.csv () | 2018-08-28 15:56:47 -0400 |
|
![]() |
Attacks3.8.R () | 2018-08-28 15:58:09 -0400 |
|