The Flooding of Urban Communities in Accra, Ghana: Assessing Population at Risk, Behavioral Response, and Fecal Contamination Open Access

Schaupp, Amanda Noelle (2013)

Permanent URL: https://etd.library.emory.edu/concern/etds/5712m660t?locale=en
Published

Abstract

Purpose: As the world becomes more urbanized, there is an increased risk of exposure to natural hazards such as flooding due to impervious surface areas without adequate parallel increases in the number of drainage networks. Flooding may also increase an individual's risk of exposure to fecal contamination containing an enteric pathogen. This study was performed to gather data to identify how many people in urban neighborhoods of Accra are at risk for exposure to flooding, why the flooding occurs, document the behaviors that could cause exposure to floodwater, and determine whether people living in a flood zone are at risk for exposure to increased fecal contamination.

Methods: Four different data collection procedures were used: 1) GIS mapping of flood areas, 2) Calculating the population at risk in each community by using census boundaries, 3) Household questionnaire on behavioral practices in response to flooding, and 4) Microbiological testing of water and soil samples for general E. coli and enteric viruses that indicate human fecal contamination.

Results:The percentage of area that flooded in Alajo, Bukom, Old Fadama, and Shiabu were 28.98%, 33.02%, 87.36%, and 48.51%, respectively. Soil, drain, and floodwater samples had high concentrations of E. coli and only a few detected norovirus contamination. In a linear regression model for E. coli concentration of soil samples both the community Old Fadama and distance to the latrine were significant. For Old Fadama the E. coli concentration increased by 4.8*103 CFU per gram and within 20 meters of a latrine it increased by 8.5*105 CFU per gram of soil.

Discussion: A resident's contact to drain water is more likely to be sporadic compared to floodwater where exposure is almost guaranteed. There are potential risk factors such as distance to a latrine and differences between communities, which influence the amount of fecal contamination. However, a resident's behavioral response to flooding can put them at an increased or decreased risk for E. coli or norovirus exposure. Short-term preventive factors such as bucketing out water during flooding could potentially increase the risk of exposure to fecal-contaminated floodwater compared to long-term preventive factors such as cement walls.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Chapter 1: Introduction- 1

Chapter 2: Literature Review- 6

Definition and causes of flooding- 6

Flooding in Accra, Ghana- 8

Historical examples of the impact of flooding- 9

Health outcomes of flooding- 11

Mortality- 11

Injuries- 12

Toxic Exposure- 12

Mental Health- 13

Rodent-borne Disease- 14

Vector-borne Disease- 14

Enteric Disease- 15

Bangladesh 1988- 16

Khartoum Sudan 1988- 17

Mozambique 2000- 19

The impact of flooding on microbial exposure- 20

Evidence of increased exposure to diarrheal pathogens from floodwater- 21

Behavioral response to flooding- 24

Chapter 3: Research Objectives and Rationale- 26

Student contribution- 28

Chapter 4: Manuscript- 29

Materials and Methods- 29

Study sites- 29

SaniPath microbiological data- 29

GIS mapping- 29

Flood areas- 29

Drain density in each flood area- 30

Distance of environmental samples from public latrine- 30

Determination of the population at risk for flooding- 31

Survey methods- 31

Cause of flooding- 31

Preventive measures in response to flooding- 33

Sample collection and microbial analysis- 34

Field collection- 34

Processing of soil samples- 34

Processing of drain water and floodwater samples- 35

E. coli membrane filtration for samples- 35

RNA and DNA extraction- 36

Quantitative PCR for norovirus GI and GII- 37

Data management- 37

Analytical methods- 37

Descriptive analysis- 37

Linear regression models- 39

Results- 40

Mapping of flood areas- 40

Percentage of area that floods and number of residents affected- 41

Causes of flooding- 42

Reported duration of flooding- 45

Behavioral responses to flooding- 46

Prevention of flooding in homes- 46

Behavioral practices for leaving the home during flooding- 47

Behavioral patterns for removing floodwaters from the home- 48

Effect of season on feces disposal in community drains- 49

E. coli concentration in environmental samples from the four study communities- 50

Multivariable linear regression model- 53

Norovirus concentration in environmental samples collected from the four study communities- 54

Discussion- 56

Community liaison as an effective way to determine flooding- 56

Number of people affected by floodwater- 57

Behavioral response and increase risk of exposure to floodwater- 57

Drain contamination with fecal matter and exposure risk posed after flooding- 59

E. coli and norovirus concentration in soil, drain water, and floodwater- 60

Linear regression modeling of E. coli concentration in soil samples- 60

Strength and Limitations- 62

Summary and Conclusions- 63

Chapter 5: Lessons Learned and Recommendations- 65

References- 66

Appendices- 74

Appendix A- 74

Appendix B- 77

About this Master's Thesis

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
School
Department
Subfield / Discipline
Degree
Submission
Language
  • English
Research field
Keyword
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Committee Members
Partnering Agencies
Last modified

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files