Communal Boundaries and Mystical Violence in the Western Mediterranean Public

Ceballos, Manuela (2016)

Permanent URL: https://etd.library.emory.edu/concern/etds/qn59q4563?locale=fr
Published

Abstract

Communal Boundaries and Mystical Violence in the Western Mediterranean, focuses on the role of violence in the formation of religious and political communities in sixteen-century North Africa and Iberia as represented in Islamic and Christian mystical texts. Scholars of Medieval and Early Modern Iberia have argued that Christian mystics and Sufis embodied the concept of convivencia (coexistence between Muslims, Jews, and Christians) because they prioritized inner belief over religious practice and law. Based on the works of members of the Discalced Carmelites and the Jazuliyya Sufi Way, the most important mystical organizations in sixteenth century Iberia and Morocco, it shows that, in fact, Christian and Muslim mystics in the Western Mediterranean channeled historical memories of interreligious conflict and used literal and symbolic violence as an ethical tool to shape individual and collective bodies and transform society as a whole. Moreover, it argues that the historiographic concept of convivencia, because it is grounded in the philosophy of liberalism, serves to reinforce the idea of the secular state as the only space in which people can peacefully coexist.

Table of Contents

TABLE OF CONTENTS

NOTES ON TRANSLITERATION

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

INTRODUCTION. FRONTIERS, METHOD, AND THE AFTERLIVES OF AL-ANDALUS 1

Changing Boundaries: 'Abd al-Karim al-Qaysi and End of Islamic Spain 12

Overview 19

CHAPTER ONE. THEORIZING BOUNDARIES: RETHINKING THE NARRATIVE OF CONVIVENCIA

Setting: The "Cordoba House" Controversy 23

A Disciplinary History of Convivencia 29

The Spanish Context: A Historical Background 48

-Making the enemy Moor: The Reconquista and the Colonial and Civil Wars 50

Américo Castro and the Origins of Convivencia 58

Conclusions 74

CHAPTER TWO. COLLAPSING BOUNDARIES: SUFISM, JIHAD, AND REFORM IN EARLY MODERN MOROCCO

Introduction: Sufism, Violence and a Moroccan performance of

convivencia 77

The Rhetoric of Muhammad ibn Yaggabsh al-Tazi 86

The Book of Jihad: Historical Background 89

Jesus and Christianity in Kitab al-Jihad 100

Jihad and Social Reform 104

Love, Authority, and Violence 109

Conclusion: Performing Divine Scripts 119

CHAPTER THREE. TRANSGRESSING BOUNDARIES: SIDI RIDWAN AL-JANUWI AND HIS COMMUNITY OF OUTSIDERS

Introduction 123

A Family of Converts and Refugees 127

Embracing Marginality 140

The Violence of Words 142

Embracing the Outsider 150

Theories of Power and Vulnerability 156

Translation and Transgression 165

Conclusion: Lineage and Power in the Early Modern Maghrib 167

CHAPTER FOUR. RE-INSCRIBING BOUNDARIES: VIOLENCE, THE OTHER, AND THE COMMUNAL BODY IN THE WRITINGS OF TERESA DE JESÚS

Setting: The Boundaries of "Spanishness": The Spanish Civil War and the Relics of Teresa de Jesús 169

Martyrdom and the "Land of the Moors" 179

Christian Peace, Crusade, and Mission: Expanding the Christian Body 188

Teresa and the Inquisition 198

Warrior Nuns 205

Violent Love: Enclosure and Subjectivity 212

Building an Enclosure and Remaking the Christian Experience 217

Conclusion 231

CONCLUSION. CONVIVENCIA AND THE BOUNDARIES OF METHOD 234

Violence, Identity, and Other Conceptual Borders 239

Further Considerations on Violence 242

Rethinking Boundaries 246

BIBLIOGRAPHY 248

About this Dissertation

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
School
Department
Degree
Submission
Language
  • English
Research Field
Mot-clé
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Committee Members
Dernière modification Preview image embargoed

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files