Consolation and cooperation: A proximate analysis of social behavior in Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) Open Access

Plotnik, Joshua (2010)

Permanent URL:


Did seemingly rare cognitive capacities in humans and non-human primates
evolve convergently in other, more distantly related species? Did this perhaps happen in
the elephant, an animal widely known for its social complexity despite the lack of
systematic evidence? Following our recent demonstration of mirror self-recognition
(considered a hallmark of self-awareness correlated with advanced empathy) in Asian
elephants (Plotnik et al. 2006), we conducted this dissertation research to further assess
this species' cognitive complexity adapting techniques designed originally for use in the
study of primate social cognition. First, we studied the elephant's capacity for consolation
(i.e. reassurance of distressed individuals) in a semi-free sanctuary in Thailand. We found
that elephants not only consoled each other following displays of distress, but bystander
elephants also seemed to adopt the emotional state of the focal individual, suggesting
emotional contagion. Second, we conducted an experimental study to investigate whether
or not elephants could learn how to cooperate when both a partner's presence and actions
were needed for success. In a task that required two elephants to each pull one of two
rope ends to retrieve a food reward, elephants learned not only to wait for their partner's
arrival before pulling, but also to inhibit pulling if their partner could not help. These
studies suggest that elephants rely on complex cognitive evaluations in their social
interactions, not unlike what we know for nonhuman primates, and that further attention
to intelligent non-primates may provide important insight into the convergent evolution
of social behavior.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Introduction 1

A General Perspective on Social and Cognitive Complexity in Elephants 3

Wild and Captive Experimental Evidence 3

Ethological Evidence from the Wild 10

Cooperation in Non-Human Animals and Attention to Levels of Analysis 11

Investigation I: Bystander Post-Distress Affiliations and Consolation in Elephants 13

An Ethological Study of Social Complexity 13

Studying Consolation and Cooperation in Tandem 16

Distress as a Focal Behavior 21

General Methods 23

Subjects 23

General Data Collection 25

Consolation Data Collection 28

Data Entry and Analysis 31

Primary Predictions 32

Results 33

Discussion 37

Investigation II: An Experimental Study of Elephant Cooperative Behavior 45

General Methods 49

Subjects 49

Experimental Setup 49

General Procedure 51

Condition I: Simultaneous Release 53

Prediction 53

Procedure and Results 54

Condition II: Delayed Release 54

Prediction 54

Procedure 54

Results 55

Prediction Evaluated 59

Condition III: No-Rope Control 60

Prediction 60

Procedure and Results 60

Prediction Evaluated 62

Discussion 62

General Discussion 69

Consolation and Cooperation Revisited 69

Limitations 72

Convergent Cognitive Evolution 73

A Note on Conservation 75

References 77

Appendix A 90

Appendix B 91

Appendix C 93

About this Dissertation

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
Subfield / Discipline
  • English
Research Field
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Committee Members
Last modified

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files