The Aesthetics of Assimilation: Non-Elite Roman Funerary Monuments, 100 B.C.E. - 200 C.E. Pubblico

Stewart, Devon Ashley (2014)

Permanent URL: https://etd.library.emory.edu/concern/etds/p5547r92k?locale=it
Published

Abstract

Funerary monuments with portraits represent the single largest genre of art commissioned by non-elite Roman patrons, especially manumitted slaves, in the city of Rome from the first century B.C.E. through the Imperial period. With little or no access to other forms of public, monumental self-representation, freedmen used funerary monuments to give shape to their social and commemorative concerns. These concerns revolve primarily around assimilation into Roman society, resolution of the destructive effects of death on the family and community, the preservation of individual and collective memories, and the assertion of status and erudition. This dissertation explores the aesthetic and commemorative strategies deployed in non-elite Roman funerary monuments to achieve these goals. Whereas previous studies have characterized non-elite patrons as passive consumers of elite visual culture who imitate elite models blindly, this dissertation demonstrates that non-elite patrons actively engaged with contemporary social, political, and visual culture in order to create innovative monuments for themselves and their families. Moreover, it privileges the sepulchral context of these monuments in order to reframe the discussion of social status in terms of anxieties over death and the obliteration of freedmen's newly acquired citizenship. Freedmen patrons appropriated the style and iconography of elite visual culture in order to contest the social dominance of the elite, and to assert concomitant claims to legitimacy in Roman society. They utilized aesthetic strategies such as repetition, reproduction, imitation and emulation in ways analogous to the Roman emulation of Greek ideal sculpture, exhibiting a high degree of visual literacy and art historical knowledge. Similarly, they used reproduction to establish a sense of communal or collective identity within their broader social group that endured over the course of centuries. This dissertation refutes the traditional contradistinction between elite and non-elite Roman art, instead emphasizing the concordances in the patrons' artistic and self-representational intrestes.

Table of Contents

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION 1

CHAPTER 1: REPRESENTATION AND VIEWING IN AN ESCHATOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK 13

TYPES OF VIEWING 16

VIEWING AND REPRESENTATION 20

RETROSPECTIVE IMAGES AND COMMEMORATION 23

ANTICIPATORY IMAGES AND PHANTASIA 33

RETROSPECTION, ANTICIPATION AND CONTINUATION 36

CONCLUSION 40

CHAPTER 2: NON-ELITE TOMB MONUMENTS AND THE MYTH OF THE "FREEDMAN AESTHETIC" 43

"ELITE" AND "NON-ELITE" IN ANCIENT ROME 46

ANCIENT AND MODERN PERSPECTIVES 59

CONCLUSION 73

CHAPTER 3: MORIBUS NON MAIORIBUS: IMAGES, ANCESTORS AND FREEDMEN AT THE END

OF THE ROMAN REPUBLIC 76

ANCESTORS AND IMAGES 77

NEW MEN AND THE "IDEOLOGY OF NOVITAS" 88

PORTRAIT AND LIKENESS 100

CONCLUSION 110

CHAPTER 4: IMITATION AND REPLICATION AS AESTHETIC STRATEGIES IN

NON-ELITE FUNERARY MONUMENTS 112

KOPIENKRITIK AND ITS LEGACY 115

REPETITION AND REPRODUCTION IN PORTRAITURE 118

EMULATION AND IMITATION 126

REPRODUCTIONS OF IDEAL SCULPTURE 146

CONCLUSION 174

CHAPTER 5: THE AESTHETIC AND SOCIAL FUNCTIONS OF REPETITION IN NON-ELITE

TOMB MONUMENTS 178

EARLY DIVERSITY IN NON-ELITE FUNERARY MONUMENTS 179

FORMULA AND REPETITION 187

CONTINUITY THROUGH THE IMPERIAL PERIOD 197

A MODEST REVIVAL 202

CONCLUSION 213

CONCLUSION 216

FIGURES 221

BIBLIOGRAPHY 242

About this Dissertation

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
School
Department
Degree
Submission
Language
  • English
Research Field
Parola chiave
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Committee Members
Ultima modifica

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files