The Equity Gap of Nutritional Health Outcomes of Children Under Five in Three South Asian Countries Since the Advent of the MDGs Open Access

Teachout, Emily (2017)

Permanent URL: https://etd.library.emory.edu/concern/etds/9593tv786?locale=en
Published

Abstract

The Equity Gap of Nutritional Health Outcomes of Children Under Five in Three South Asian Countries since the advent of the MDGs

By Emily Teachout

Background:

Over the past decade, there has been an increased focus at a global level on improving the nutrition of children under 5. Progress toward this goal has been monitored since the MDGs in 2000. However, a well-documented criticism of the MDGs is its lack of focus on health equity. The SDGs have been applauded for their renewed focus toward improving equity. Still, neither set of UN development goals have nutritional health indicators stratified by wealth. South Asia experienced a large decrease in undernutrition in children under 5 from 2000-2015. However, we know very little about the regional trends in health equity for children from the poorest households over the period of the Millennium Development Goals.

Methods and Findings:

We conducted a secondary data analysis using 6 DHS surveys from three countries in South Asia: Pakistan (1991 and 2013), Bangladesh (1999 and 2014), and Nepal (2001 and 2011). Survey weights were applied to the data sets to produce population level estimates. We used a variety of methods to explore the changes in the distribution of the prevalence and the odds ratios of stunting across wealth quintiles for children under five. We conducted multivariate logistic regression using SAS 9.2 to produce odds ratios of stunting and wasting by wealth quintile for each survey separately using SAS-callable SUDAAN. We found that across all surveys, the changes in prevalence of stunting at a national population level masked sluggish improvements for children from the poorest 40% of households.

Conclusion:

The poor are being left behind as the South Asia region makes large progress toward the reduction of undernutrition. There is an urgent need for improved targeting of public health resources to the most vulnerable and hard to reach children. Further, there is a need for the UN development goals to include indicators that stratify by economic status so that countries are held accountable for more than an overall prevalence reduction.


Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Distribution Agreement

Approval Sheet

Abstract

Acknowledgements

List of Tables and Figures

Chapter 1: Introduction

Purpose of this Study

Significance Statement

Definition of Terms

Chapter 2: Literature Review

The Global Move Toward Better Nutritional Health Outcomes

Comparing Indicators from MDGs and SDGs

Indicators of Malnutrition: Stunting and Wasting

Measures of Socioeconomic Status

The Wealth Index

Stunting and Wasting: Relative vs. Absolute Measures of Wealth

Introduction to Measurements of Inequities in Health Outcomes

Concentration Curve and Concentration Index

Simple Proportions

Other Proposed Methods for Dichotomous Variables

Previous Studies that have Explored the Equity Gap in Nutritional Health Outcomes Since the MDGs

Study #1: Wagstaff, 2014

Study #2: Bredenkamp, Buisman, & Van de Poel, 2014

Study #3: Greffeuille et al., 2016

Study #4: Pathak & Singh, 2011

Overall Trends in Nutritional Health for South Asia and Identified Regional Challenges

Nepal

Pakistan

Bangladesh

Equity of Program Coverage and Targeting of MCNH Interventions

Chapter 3: Manuscript

Abstract

Keywords

Introduction

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Appendix A: Extended Tables and Figures

Table 1A. Cross-tabulations Full Table: Bangladesh

Table 1B. Odds Ratios Full Table: Bangladesh

Table 1C. Stunting Contingency Table: Bangladesh

Table 1D. Wasting Contingency Table: Bangladesh

Table 1E. Combined Undernourished Contingency Table: Bangladesh

Table 2A. Cross-tabulations Full Table: Pakistan

Table 2B. Odds Ratios Full Table: Pakistan

Table 2C. Stunting Contingency Table: Pakistan

Table 2D. Wasting Contingency Table: Pakistan

Table 2E. Combined Undernourished Contingency Table: Pakistan

Table 3A. Cross-tabulations Full Table: Nepal

Table 3B. Odds Ratios Full Table: Nepal

Table 3C. Stunting Contingency Table: Nepal

Table 3D. Wasting Contingency Table: Nepal

Table 3E. Combined Undernourished Contingency Table: Nepal

About this Master's Thesis

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
School
Department
Degree
Submission
Language
  • English
Research field
Keyword
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Partnering Agencies
Last modified

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files