Organized Labor in a Globalized World: The Impact of Increasing International Economic Integration on the Strategies of Trade Unions Open Access

Nahmias, Gabriel (2013)

Permanent URL: https://etd.library.emory.edu/concern/etds/765371905?locale=en
Published

Abstract

Evidence is mounting that economic globalization has had a detrimental effect on intrastate inequality, especially in industrialized nations. One possible causal mechanism by which to explain this relationship is the declining bargaining power of labor and, particularly, organized labor. This work argues that as a result of trade competition and the threat of outsourcing, trade unions are less capable of demanding wages, benefits, and job security from employers. Furthermore, unions will respond to declining bargaining power by augmenting their lobbying efforts for human capital and infrastructure investments as a means of fortifying labor's relative position in negotiation, and thus its ability to demand compensation and job security. Furthermore, it is argued that unions will increase their pressure on the government for unemployment insurance to offset declining security in the marketplace.

A two stage methodology is adopted to evaluate the validity of this theory. Panel data from 30 industrialized nations supplies evidence that globalization diminishes the effect of union strength on compensation and some types of employment protection, while increasing the positive impact of trade unions on investment in training, infrastructure, and unemployment insurance. Following this statistical analysis, unions in two sectors of the British economy, manufacturing and construction, are examined to show that these effects are a conscious decision on the part of union leaders and that they are indeed the result of globalization.

Collectively, the evidence suggests that globalization is indeed causing unions to emphasize productivity in their demands for compensation. Furthermore, the cross-national analysis provides support for the claim that unions are pressuring the government for increased social spending to support of the working class during periods of unemployment, though the micro foundations could not be established in the case study. Contrary to theory, it appears that unions are still pushing for government employment protection, perhaps even more than employment insurance, as a consequence of globalization. Finally, the case study makes apparent that trade unions have a number of other policy responses at their disposal which theory does not take into account.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Introduction: Unheard-of Wealth and Unheard-of Poverty 1

Literature Review: 4

The Inequality of Bargaining Power 4

Globalization Has Gone Too Far 6

Win Wage Gains and Promote Job Security 10

Theory: Same Ends, Different Means 13

Cross National Time Series Analysis Methodology 15

A Few Minor Heroic Assumptions 15

Rich and Free 17

Variable Overview 18

Explanatory Variables: 18

Globalization 18

Union Strength 21

Control Variables: 22

Fixed Effects 22

Wage Coordination 24

Regime Ideology 25

Technological Change 25

Deindustrialization 27

Exposure to Globalization 28

Competitive Advantage 28

Cross National Time Series Analysis Results 30

Win Wage Gain: Labor Share 30

Promote Job Security 33

Severance Pay 34

Advance notice 35

Unemployment Rate 37

Competitive Advantage 38

Training 38

Infrastructure 39

Maintaining Labor's Welfare: Unemployment Insurance 43

Cross National Conclusion 45

Case Study: A Manufacturing Union in the United Kingdom 46

Labor in Defense: A Brief History of the British Labor Movement 51

Labor in Dispute: Strike Behavior Since 1972 55

Labor in Dialogue: A Decade and a Half of Testimony 58

Labor in DisUNITEy: Same Union, Different Strategies 66

Labor in Person 71

Discussion: Organized Labor in a Globalized World 73

Conclusion: There is [Still] Power in a Union 77

Tables & Figures 79

Data Sources 140

Works Cited 142

Appendix 151

Countries & Years for Which Both Union Strength & Globalization Data is Available 151

Descriptive Statistics for Explanatory & Control Variables 152

Descriptive Statistics for Dependent Variables 153

Conditional Coefficient of Union Strength for All Dependent Variables as Derived from Full Model 154

Conditional Effect of One Standard Deviation Increase in Union Strength as Derived from Full Model 155

Conditional Effect of One Standard Deviation Increase in Union Strength as Derived from Full Model 156

Trade Union Membership of Trades Union Congress 157

About this Master's Thesis

Rights statement
  • Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
School
Department
Degree
Submission
Language
  • English
Research field
Keyword
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor
Committee Members
Last modified

Primary PDF

Supplemental Files