The Systematic Socrates: Hegel as Moral Philosopher Open Access

Abstract

Abstract The Systematic Socrates: Hegel as Moral Philosopher By James A. Dunson III

My dissertation reopens a philosophical dispute: Hegel's critique of Kantian moral philosophy. It argues that the standard characterization of this dispute involves a superficial reading of both Kant and Hegel. My reconstruction of Hegel's moral philosophy recognizes his unique contribution to this area of philosophy, while outlining a deeper criticism of Kant. Far from being a merely historical project, however, this reconstruction raises several questions regarding the nature of philosophical inquiry: (1) In what sense, if any, is moral philosophy 'practical'? (2) What is the proper philosophical reply to the challenges posed by dogmatism and skepticism? 3) What substantive ends, if any, result from studying moral philosophy?

I argue that Hegel revives the pre-Kantian substantive ends of self-knowledge and some form of philosophical satisfaction (e.g. Stoic ataraxia or Spinoza's blessedness). He recovers an often-overlooked form of moral and practical philosophy: the Bildung (the education or self-formation) of one's philosophical understanding, which requires the training of one's judgment. Yet Hegel's revival of this tradition is also an attempt to complete Kant's own practical philosophy. By overcoming what he deems to be the existential disorder of the Kantian moral subject, Hegel's version of autonomy results in being `at home in the world.' I claim that the revival of these substantive ends does not require the reversion to a pre-Kantian form of speculative metaphysics. The close connection between Hegel's systematic thought and his version of skepticism provides the key insight into how this is accomplished.

Table of Contents

CONTENTS

ABBREVIATIONS 1

INTRODUCTION 2

Hegel's Revival of Socratic Ignorance

What is Practical Philosophy?

1 MAKING KANT EXPLICIT 33

A Theologian in Disguise?

What is Dogmatism?

Skepticism, Solved or Dissolved?

An Entire Nest of Contradictions

2 HEGEL AS MORAL PHILOSOPHER 89

Kant, Hegel, and Ancient Skepticism

Reconciliation and Consolation

The Satisfactions of Stoicism and Spinozism

3 HEGEL AS PRAGMATIC METAPHYSICIAN 145

Autonomy as Beisichselbstsein

A Socratic Transformation of Metaphysics

The Prophet in Reverse

4 MAKING ETHICAL LIFE EXPLICIT 182

Liberty, Ancient and Modern

Autonomy, Public and Private

Socratic Ignorance and Irony

BIBLIOGRAPHY 214

About this Dissertation

Rights statement

• Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.

School	Laney Graduate School
Department	Philosophy
Degree	PhD
Submission	Dissertation
Language	English
Research Field	Philosophy History, European
Keyword	self-knowledge moral philosophy Socrates Hegel Kant ethics
Committee Chair / Thesis Advisor	Verene, Donald Phillip, Emory University
Committee Members	Sullivan, Michael, Emory University Makkreel, Rudolf A, Emory University

Last modified

Primary PDF

Thumbnail	Title	Date Uploaded	Actions
	The Systematic Socrates: Hegel as Moral Philosopher ()	2018-08-28 11:49:26 -0400	Press to Select an action Download

Supplemental Files

Thumbnail	Title	Date Uploaded	Actions